Dungeon Crawler Carl

A Pitch to Water Down Dungeon Crawler Carl for Children

Congratulations, Crawlers.

3 min readYahoo Entertainment
A Pitch to Water Down Dungeon Crawler Carl for Children

The pitch to turn *Dungeon Crawler Carl* into a bedtime story for children is adorable, impractical, and the kind of idea that gets a fan site a very stern letter from Borant's legal department. A reader at Future, writing to promote the concept of a Princess Donut, narrated spinoff called *Bedtime Stories For Mongo*, has proposed exactly what you would expect from someone who has not yet been crushed by the collapse timer: a sanitized retelling of the crawl, filtered through a cat who worries about her dinosaur's feelings. The logic is sound for a parent who wants to share the franchise with an eight-year-old. The logic is catastrophic for anyone who understands what the dungeon actually does to people.

Let us be clear about the practical reality. The crawl is not a choose-your-own-adventure where Donut can skip the gore. The crawl is a floor-by-floor descent into a system that measures your trauma in loot drops. A version of this story that removes the swearing, the raunch, and the dismemberment is not a retelling; it is a different story with the same character names. The author has already made his priorities plain, as noted in Dungeon Crawler Carl Author Puts Books First Over Peacock Show, and the series resumes its proper descent on January 20th according to Crawl resumes January 20th, Crawlers: your new descent begins. The pipeline is already spoken for. A children's spinoff would require a separate creative team, a separate budget, and a separate set of approvals from a Syndicate that has never shown interest in making the crawl palatable to a human child.

The real question is not whether Donut *could* tell the story differently. She absolutely could. She is a celebrity with opinions about interior design and a grudge against Cocker Spaniels. The question is whether the audience wants a version of the dungeon that has been edited for emotional safety. The answer, based on the comic preview in Issue 57 Preview: Crawlers, Your Next Collapse Timer Is Here, is no. Crawlers do not read this series for the wholesome cat-and-dinosaur bonding. They read it because the system is unfair, the bosses are cruel, and Carl keeps walking. A sanitized Donut would be a toy, not a crawler, and the dungeon does not make toys.

If Matt Dinniman ever writes *Bedtime Stories For Mongo*, it will be because he found a way to make the humor land without the blood. That is his decision, not ours, and certainly not a fan site's. Until then, the takeaway is this: the franchise is about to be overwhelmed with news, as the writer correctly predicts, and every announcement will test whether the crawl remains the crawl or becomes something the sponsors can sell to a younger demographic. Watch the collapse timer. That is the only bedtime story that matters.

From Yahoo Entertainment

When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission.

I'm buzzing through the Dungeon Crawler Carl series this year, and my 8-year-old daughter gets so jealous every time she sees it. She loves cats, dinosaurs, and adventure, so in her mind, there's no reason she shouldn't be able to read it as well or watch the upcoming series when it premieres for those with a Peacock subscription.

Read the original at Yahoo Entertainment