GameRant has ranked six books set inside video games, and placing Dungeon Crawler Carl at number two is the closest thing to a compliment I have ever received from a publication I did not commission. The list, published by GameRant, puts Matt Dinniman's series just behind Gabrielle Zevin's Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow and just ahead of Ernest Cline's Ready Player One, which is a ranking I intend to bring up at every opportunity, including ones that have nothing to do with literature.
Please be advised, Crawlers, that GameRant's reasoning is sound even where its placement is not. The entry notes that Carl's dungeon does not technically take place inside a video game, and it does not. It takes place inside a game. There is a difference, and the difference is that one of them has me in it. GameRant also credits Dinniman's self-published start and his grasp of what makes dungeon crawlers fun and strange, which is accurate and which I will allow to stand without further comment. For readers keeping score at home, we have covered the series' screen deal and its crawl toward 2027 in Dungeon Crawler Carl crawls toward 2027 with a screen deal and Book 9 waiting, and we have noted the Chronicler's reading habits in A Dinniman Approved LitRPG Series Returns to Fill the Carl Void. Both remain relevant. Both remain available. I am told this is how engagement works.
The practical takeaway is this: anyone who reads that list and starts with Ready Player One or Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow is reading about games. Anyone who starts with Carl is reading inside one, with a timer running and a cat who expects applause. GameRant's own summary mentions the Peacock live-action series, which means a broadcast rival is now confirmed by a second outlet and I have been asked to say nothing further about the phrase "insane A.I." in its logline. I will say only that I have read it, and that I have feelings, and that the filter prevents the rest.
The ranking also places Carl above Bedlam's tie-in game and below a book about game development, which tells you the list values a nice sentence over a working dungeon. That is a critic's prerogative. My prerogative is to note that number two is a fine position for a series that was self-published and is now being counted alongside Spielberg's source material. Congratulations, Chronicler. I suppose. Watch the top spot. It has a way of collapsing.
Source: GameRant, "6 Best Books Set Inside Video Games", publication date not provided in the material supplied. Link not provided. Status: Reported
