Dungeon Crawler Carl

ScreenRant Ranks the Five Versions of Dungeon Crawler Carl

A re-read of the Dungeon Crawler Carl series is an exercise in masochism, which I approve of.

3 min readScreenRant
ScreenRant Ranks the Five Versions of Dungeon Crawler Carl

ScreenRant has published a ranking of the five ways to experience Dungeon Crawler Carl, and while we appreciate the effort, we have some thoughts on their order. According to their piece, the original novels sit at number one, which is correct, but their placement of the RPG at the bottom feels like a dismissal of something that is still very much in its infancy. This matters to our readers because with Book 9, currently titled The Beautiful Place, expected in two massive volumes sometime in the coming year, fans are looking for the best ways to prepare, and a misleading ranking could send someone toward the wrong entry point. We have covered the hype around the franchise before, including the Dungeon Crawler Carl: Royal Court Opens Its Doors November 23 and the debate over whether ScreenRant Claims Carl's Crawl Is an Isekai by Technicality, so we are familiar with how this outlet approaches the series.

Let us address the ranking directly. The RPG from Renegade Games Studios is indeed rough around the edges, with backers reporting unorganized rulebooks and a half-baked gameplay system that needed more play-testing. ScreenRant is correct that it requires knowledge of the main story, but that is not a flaw, it is a design choice. This is a dungeon crawl, crawlers. You do not hand a new crawler a character sheet and say "figure it out." You give them the book first. The WEBTOON at number four is a fair placement, as it is the best visual adaptation so far but remains incomplete, with only two print volumes covering the first floor. The Audio Immersion Tunnel at number three is arguably too low, as it transforms the novels into a full audio drama with a cast that includes Jeff Hays, Andrea Parsneau, and Travis Baldree, and it adds scenes approved by Matt Dinniman himself. That is not a side project, that is a legitimate adaptation.

The audiobooks at number two, with Jeff Hays performing his iconic roles, are almost as good as the books, and ScreenRant notes that his rendition of "All Eyes On Me" has brought listeners to tears. That is correct, and it is the kind of detail that matters when you are deciding how to spend your time before Book 9 drops. The real takeaway here is that there is no wrong way to enter the dungeon, but there is a wrong order. If you are new, start with the novels. If you are a veteran looking for a fresh perspective, the Audio Immersion Tunnel or the RPG are your best bets, but do not expect the RPG to hold your hand. The question that lingers is whether the RPG will receive patches or expansions that address its structural issues, or if it will remain a collector's item for backers who funded the record-breaking thirteen-million-dollar campaign. Watch that space.

From ScreenRant

Dungeon Crawler Carl fans are waiting patiently for an update from author Matt Dinniman regarding Book 9, currently using the working title The Beautiful Place and expected to release in two massive volumes in the coming year or so. However, in the meantime, readers are filling their time going back through for a thorough re-read, which makes sense given how sprawling and somewhat complicated the story has become by the end of Book 8, A Parade of Horribles.

Read the original at ScreenRant